• ByteOnBikes@slrpnk.net
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    edit-2
    4 days ago

    In the 90s, calling yourself a flat earther was a opportunity to have a fun and yet silly conversation about belief in science. During that time, both people KNEW that the earth was round. It was an exercise in creativity and played straight for laughs.

    But somewhere in the 2000, some people didn’t realize the satire. They actually BELIEVED in it.

    There’s a line of shitposting like with anything.

    Shitposting is an art. It’s satire.

    Then there’s actual shitty people who don’t realize that the good shit posts harm nobody. Where shitty people posting disgusting racist things under the guise of Shitposting are too stupid to understand the nuance.

    This commenter said it best:

    To the people who think what OP did was completely normal and something everyone does, (and I hate to use this phrase) check the “ratio” here. Nobody thinks this is normal. You and OP are in the slim minority spewing vile shit about people in your lives. It’s cruel and childish. You’d be smart to learn from OP’s predicament before you find yourself in the exact same situation with everyone you know hating you because you thought it was perfectly normal to constantly trash talk them behind their back. It’s not normal. Not everyone is doing it. Assholes like OP and apparently yourself are doing it. And it clearly can bite you in the ass. As I said in my initial comment, these kinds of things can have serious real world consequences. So you may wanna wise up and start being a respectable human being ;)

    • trashgirlfriend@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      4 days ago

      Shitposting is an art. It’s satire.

      I might get cooked for this but it’s just not.

      As a person who has been shit posting for at least a decade at this point, 99% of shit posting is either just saying something stupid on purpose or being a cunt to someone.

      “Shitposting is an art” is some shit a dweeb says online to make themselves look interesting because “I like to say dumb shit for attention” sounds a lot worse.

      Like sure, sometimes it’s funny to be a cunt to someone online (within reason) but let’s not pretend it’s something profound.

      Furthermore, the fact that it’s not something profound but just dumbass behavior done for laughs is the reason it can be misunderstood by honest dumbasses.

      • thebestaquaman@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        3 days ago

        I’ll defend shitposting here, because I think you’re simplifying it a bit too much.

        Shitposting is so much more than “saying dumb stuff for shits n’ giggles”. First of all, as with anything else, there are good and bad shitposts. A good shitpost usually contains a solid undertone of irony or sarcasm. An important part of the humour is not just in “being dumb” it’s about using a statement that is dumb in a very specific way in combination with a specific context in order to create something funny.

        Furthermore, a good shitpost uses exaggeration in a good way. The reader should preferably be “lured into” the post, not realising it’s a shitpost, before the notch is turned to 11 revealing that it was a shitpost. This adds an extra layer of humor and social commentary: The fact that the post at first seems believable forces you to recon with what kind of things you would actually believe someone could write. It also makes the target of the humor clear.

        Shitposting may not be high art, but calling it “just being a cunt to someone” is missing the mark. “Just being a cunt to someone” is exactly that, and it’s not shitposting.

            • trashgirlfriend@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              3 days ago

              Legit, what do you want my response to be to that.

              My whole argument was that internet people think shit posting is something profound but it’s just shitposting.

              Maybe I should have posted a crying wojak saying it so it’s Real Shitpost™ Art certified.

              • thebestaquaman@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                2
                ·
                2 days ago

                To be fair, I didn’t expect you to respond at all, and really just wanted to point out that calling a stranger you know nothing about a “dweeb” in response to something they wrote is a prime example of “just being a cunt to someone”. You didn’t need to respond, but you chose to do so by being a cunt.

                Regardless, I think you missed some of the sarcasm in what I was writing (which, in hindsight, isn’t very clear). My point isn’t that shitposting is some form of high art. It’s that it’s a form of humor that amounts to more than saying provocative stuff or being a cunt. At it’s best, a shitpost can even contain some social commentary in the same way as caricatures can. Of course, as with all other humor, there are plenty of bad shitposts out there too, which are often just trolls trying to stir up shit.